• What is UNN?
  • Why UNN?
  • Our Team
  • Support Us
Friday, June 2, 2023
  • Login
  • Home
  • Featured stories
  • Editors Choice
  • Trending Stories
  • News
  • Africa Today
  • Opinion
  • Literature
  • Videos
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Featured stories
  • Editors Choice
  • Trending Stories
  • News
  • Africa Today
  • Opinion
  • Literature
  • Videos
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
UNN Times
No Result
View All Result
Home Africa Today

Justice Kanyeihamba Loses Case on Threat to Deny Right to Bail

Moses Kalaire | UNN Times ReporterbyMoses Kalaire | UNN Times Reporter
January 16, 2023
in Africa Today, News, Uganda
0
Justice Kanyeihamba Loses Case on Threat to Deny Right to Bail

Despite being relegated to a wheelchair - Retired Justice Georg Kanyeihamba still has the guts to challenge illegalities within the set-up system.

6
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

KAMPALA – The Constitutional Court has dismissed a case in which retired Justice George Kanyeihamba had challenged the move to scrap bail for suspects on capital offenses.

In 2021, Kanyeihamba together with John Solomon Nabuyanda, Edrine Price Bodda, Alex Wavamunno, Ronald William Asiimwe, and Simon Ssenyonga sued the attorney General, the president, Yoweri Museveni, and the National Resistance Movement-NRM for their attempt to scrap bail for suspects on capital offenses.

RELATED STORIES

Ugandans Run to Court Seeking to Nullify Anti Homosexuality Act

Ugandans Run to Court Seeking to Nullify Anti Homosexuality Act

May 30, 2023
Biden Threatens Uganda with Sanctions Over Anti-Homosexuality Law

Biden Threatens Uganda with Sanctions Over Anti-Homosexuality Law

May 30, 2023
MTN Uganda Gives NSSF Ugx31.5bn in Dividend

MTN Uganda Gives NSSF Ugx31.5bn in Dividend

May 30, 2023
Museveni Approves Anti-Homosexuality Law

Museveni Approves Anti-Homosexuality Law

May 29, 2023

While presiding over the 4th annual memorial lecture of the slain Chief Justice Benedicto Kiwanuka, President Yoweri Museveni argued that granting bail to suspects involved in capital offences was a provocation. He pledged to use political and legal means to see to it that bail for capital offenders (suspects) was legally denied.

Soon, the president held a meeting with the NRM caucus and cabinet to discuss the matter. A cabinet memo said to have leaked indicated that Attorney General Kiryowa Kiwanuka had proposed that Article 23(6) (b) of the Constitution be amended to provide that a person accused of committing an offense triable by both the High Court and subordinate courts, shouldn’t be granted bail until after 180 days or trial commencement, or when the Director of Public Prosecutions -DPP discontinues proceedings.

He also proposed that Article 23(4) (b) and Section 25 of the Police Act, both of which require a suspect to be released on police bond if not charged in court within 48 hours, be changed to ‘forty-eight business hours.’

The proposal raised dust among political leaders from the opposition and the ruling NRM party, the academia, and rights activists. They condemned the move as unconstitutional and to an extent, a plot to silence voices critical of the government.

The petitioners hence moved under Article 50 of the Constitution, which provides that any person who claims that a fundamental or other right or freedom guaranteed under this Constitution has been infringed or threatened, is entitled to apply to a competent court for redress that may include compensation.

The government through the office of the attorney general opposed the application saying that it was wrongfully before the Constitutional Court and was based on hearsay. In one affidavit sworn by the Head of Public Service and Secretary to Cabinet, Lucy Mbonye Nakyobe, she held that minutes from cabinet meetings are private and cannot be accessed by the public, hence rendering the allegations regarding the cabinet memo null and void.

It was also argued that the President had been wrongfully sued because he’s protected under Article 98 (4), which provides that a sitting president is not liable to proceedings under any court. As for the NRM, they didn’t see why they had been sued since as a party, they often meet to discuss issues before taking a decision.

Now, in her ruling on behalf of the panel of Constitutional Court justices, Justice Monica Mugenyi, says that the application was wrongfully filed before that court. She says that Article 137 (3) (a,) which provides for Constitutional interpretations is clearly inapplicable to the present set of facts given that there is no Act of Parliament or any other law or indeed anything down by the authority of any specific legislation that has been challenged.

She held that if the petitioners felt that there was a threat to a constitutional right, they ought to have filed a petition before a competent court, not the Constitutional Court as provided for under Article 50 (1).

“In the result, I am satisfied that this petition is misconceived and improperly before this Court” ruled the Justice.

The Justice also didn’t find the act of calling a party caucus meeting per se to constitute a constitutional violation. She opined that a meeting convened to discuss legal reforms would not amount to a meeting for an unconstitutional purpose unless it can be demonstrated that the subject of discussion would amount to a contravention or abrogation of the Constitution.

She made reference to Supreme Court Judgement in the case of the Attorney General v David Tinyefunza in which it was held that a mere mention of a constitutional violation is not sufficient to establish a cause of action before the court. She says, the matter before the Court ought to depend on the interpretation of constitutional provisions for determination.

“In this case, all that is furnished in the petition are copies of newspaper references to a cabinet meeting on the subject of bail. The petition does not present any formal proposals, simply alluding to a memorandum of proposed amendments to Article 23 (6) or the Constitution and Section 25 of the Police Act that was allegedly authored by the Hon. Attorney General, without availing it to the court” ruled the justice, adding that even if the memorandum had been availed, the court must be on guard to avoid premature adjudications and entanglement in abstract or speculative disputes between potential petitioners.

She hence dismissed the petition with no costs. Other Justices on the panel, Frederick Egonda Ntende, Elizabeth Musoke, Christopher Madrama, and Christopher Gashirabake agreed with her judgment.  The lead Petitioner, Retired Justice George Kanyeihamba said he was dissatisfied with the ruling of the court, saying he would appeal the same before the Supreme Court. He said the Justice of the Constitutional Court seems to have acted to the wish of someone else rather than follow the law and determine the case he is confident is right before them.

It should be noted that only retired Justice Kanyeihamba and Alex Wavamuno were still part of the case. The other four withdrew from it.

Tags: . Uganda’s President Yoweri MuseveniJustice George KanyeihambaRight to Bail
Previous Post

NUP-Busoga Branch Members Welcome Suspension of their Leaders

Next Post

Traditional Healer on the run after Death of Mother

Related Posts

Biden Threatens Uganda with Sanctions Over Anti-Homosexuality Law

byMoureen Nanono | UNN Times Reporter
May 30, 2023
0
Biden Threatens Uganda with Sanctions Over Anti-Homosexuality Law

WASHINGTON – US President Joe Biden on Monday slammed Uganda’s draconian new law against homosexuality as a grave human rights...

Read more

Ugandan Army Confirms Casualties in Al Shabaab Attack

byMoses Kalaire | UNN Times Reporter
May 28, 2023
0
Ugandan Army Confirms Casualties in Al Shabaab Attack

KAMPALA –President Yoweri Museveni confirmed early on Sunday there had been casualties during Somalia's Islamist group al Shabaab – attack...

Read more

How Deliberate Disorganisation is Keeping Uganda Hooked onto Loans Domestically

byUNN Times Editor | UNN Times Editorial
May 18, 2023
0
How Refugees are Destroying Uganda’s Environment

By Oweyegha-Afunaduula Should I start by defining organisation? But its Ok…let me start differently and will get back to the...

Read more

NRM Government 37th Year Anniversary – the Bouquets and Barbs

byUNN Times Editor | UNN Times Editorial
January 28, 2023
0
Ofwono Opondo on Namuganza Censure, Erias Lukwago and Gen Saleh’s Memo

By Ofwono Opondo KAMPALA - President Yoweri Museveni and the NRM government marked 37 years since being worn-in on January...

Read more

President Museveni Tasks Schools to equip Learners with Appropriate Skills

byRonald Mugabi | UNN Times Reporter
January 14, 2023
0
President Museveni Tasks Schools to equip Learners with Appropriate Skills

LIRA –President Yoweri Museveni has called upon institutions of education to prepare their learners with skills that would enable them...

Read more

President Museveni will Appear on the 2026 Ballot Paper –VP Alupo Assures Ugandans

bySophie Mutesi | UNN Times Reporter
January 9, 2023
0
President Museveni will Appear on the 2026 Ballot Paper –VP Alupo Assures Ugandans

ENTEBBE - Vice President –Rtd Maj Jesca Alupo announced on Sunday that his boss Yoweri Museveni would run for 2026...

Read more
Next Post
Traditional Healer on the run after Death of Mother

Traditional Healer on the run after Death of Mother

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

About us

UNN is a new people powered TV channel, Radio station and Newspaper leading the revolution. We’re a media outlet focused on inspiring and empowering you while telling the truth, because as they say, the truth will set you free.

Recent

Ugandans Run to Court Seeking to Nullify Anti Homosexuality Act

Biden Threatens Uganda with Sanctions Over Anti-Homosexuality Law

MTN Uganda Gives NSSF Ugx31.5bn in Dividend

Museveni Approves Anti-Homosexuality Law

Why Junior Minister-Nandutu Lost Bid to Block her Trial in Iron Sheet Theft

Does Environmental Justice in Uganda Matter Anymore?

Follow Us

Tweets by GetUNN

Facebook

© 2023 UNN Times

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Featured stories
  • Editors Choice
  • Trending Stories
  • News
  • Africa Today
  • Opinion
  • Literature
  • Videos
  • Sports

© 2023

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.